Follow me

When Your Product Is Trust, and Trust Gets Recalled

When Your Product Is Trust, and Trust Gets Recalled

Let me start by telling you what this article is not about.

It is not about the sanctions. It is not about the International Criminal Court, or the politics behind the case that triggered all of this. I am not a political commentator, and I have no interest in litigating any of that here. That sits well outside my lane.

What I am interested in is much simpler, and if you work in marketing or brand strategy, it is far more useful. I want to talk about what happens to a company’s positioning the moment it becomes a visible player in a geopolitical event, whether it chose to be or not. Because positioning gets affected the second a brand is seen to act. And it doesn’t just affect the company in the headline. It affects every company watching from the sidelines.

Positioning gets affected the second a brand is seen to act. And not just for the company in the headline for every company watching.

The Moment the Promise Broke

Here is the incident, kept as simple as I can make it. In 2025, the chief prosecutor of the ICC, Karim Khan, lost access to his Microsoft email. He had been personally sanctioned by the US government, and as an American company, Microsoft was caught in the middle of that. Khan ended up moving to Proton, a Swiss email provider, to keep working.

Now, the exact details of who switched off what got messy and disputed; Microsoft has said it did not cut services to the court itself, and there was back-and-forth about how it actually played out. I am deliberately not going to get stuck in that. The mechanics matter less than the signal.

And the signal that went out to every government, every court, every company outside the United States was this: the tools you run your entire operation on can be affected by decisions made in Washington, and you don’t get a vote. That is the moment that matters. Not the politics of it. The positioning of it.

What These Companies Were Actually Selling

Think about what a company like Microsoft, Amazon, or Google actually sells to a large organisation. It is not really software. It is not really storage. Those are the features. What they sell, the thing underneath everything, is dependability. The promise is: build your whole business on us, and we will be the boring, reliable, always-on ground you stand on. Don’t worry about us. We’re a utility.

That promise is the entire product. And for years it worked beautifully, because it was believable. Then the ICC incident made a lot of people around the world ask a question they had never seriously asked before: what happens if the ground I’m standing on answers to someone else’s government?

They don’t sell software. They sell dependability. That promise IS the product, which is exactly why this hurt.

The Bit Nobody Explains: the CLOUD Act

Here is the piece of the puzzle most people don’t know about, and it’s the most useful thing in this whole article. There is a US law called the CLOUD Act, passed in 2018. In plain English, it says that any US-based technology company can be compelled by US authorities to hand over data it controls, even if that data is stored on the other side of the world.

Read that again, because it’s the whole story. It does not matter where the data physically sits. Your files can be in a data centre in Frankfurt, in Paris, in a facility with a German flag on the door. If the company that runs it is American, or owned by an American parent, US law can still reach it. The location of the building is not the deciding factor. The nationality of the company is.

This isn’t a fringe theory, either. In June 2025, Microsoft’s own French subsidiary confirmed this under oath at a French Senate hearing, stating plainly that it could not guarantee data would be protected from US authorities, even for data held in France under a French-marketed “sovereign” offering. When the provider itself says it on the record, the debate is basically over.

THE CLOUD ACT, IN ONE LINE

A US company can be compelled to hand over data it controls, no matter which country that data physically sits in. What decides exposure is the company’s nationality, not the data centre’s location.

How the Rest of the World Reacted

Once that clicks, you can see why the reaction outside the US was so fast. The ICC itself moved off Microsoft to an open-source suite called openDesk, built under a German “digital sovereignty” initiative. The Dutch government started formally reviewing how dependent it was on American tech and looking at alternatives. Phrases like “digital sovereignty” jumped from academic conferences into actual government purchasing decisions in about two years.

And a whole category of non-American providers suddenly had the best marketing message they could ever hope for, handed to them for free: “we cannot be weaponised against you.” Swiss providers like Proton, European cloud players like OVHcloud and Scaleway, and open-source options like Nextcloud, all of them woke up to a positioning gift. They didn’t have to claim it. The situation claimed it for them.

The Giants Respond, Fast, and by Name

Now watch what the American companies did, because this is positioning happening in real time. None of them sat still. Every one of them moved to defend its standing, and interestingly, they did it in different ways.

  • Microsoft declared its EU Data Boundary complete in early 2025, then went further in June 2025 with a Sovereign Public Cloud and a Sovereign Private Cloud. It even set up a European board of directors made up of European nationals to oversee its datacenter operations there.
  • Amazon (AWS) committed €7.8 billion to a European Sovereign Cloud, launching its first region in Germany, run by German subsidiaries with EU-based staff, its own independent advisory board, and its own root certificate authority. Architecturally, it’s the cleanest separation of the lot.
  • Google took a partner route in Germany; Deutsche Telekom’s T-Systems acts as a data trustee holding the encryption keys outside Google’s own reach; in France, it co-founded a separate French legal entity called S3NS, operating under French law.
  • Oracle already had an EU Sovereign Cloud up and running.

These are not small gestures. They are real engineering and real money, and for a lot of organisations they genuinely solve the compliance problem. That deserves to be said plainly.

But Here’s the Honest Catch

For all that effort, there’s a limit that no amount of engineering has gotten past yet, and it’s worth stating simply because it’s the truth. Every one of these sovereign offerings still ends up, at the very bottom, owned by a US company. And a US company is subject to US law, including the CLOUD Act. As one analyst put it neatly, the different architectures all “terminate at the same legal endpoint.”

Rebranding a European region as “sovereign” adds real controls, but it doesn’t change who ultimately owns the company. That is not me making an accusation, remember; Microsoft’s own French arm confirmed exactly this under oath. The controls are real. The ceiling is also real. Whether the controls are enough depends entirely on how sensitive your data is and how you personally weigh the risk. For most businesses, they’re fine. For a court investigating a government, clearly they were not.

The controls are real. The ceiling is also real. Both things are true at once and that’s the whole conversation.

The Positioning Lesson for Everyone Else

So what’s the takeaway if you’re in brand or marketing and you don’t run a cloud company? It’s this. A brand’s positioning can be reshaped by events it never chose to be part of. Microsoft did not ask to be in the middle of a sanctions story. But the moment it was seen to act, its core promise, dependability, took a visible hit with an entire class of international customers. That happened whether it was fair or not.

And the flip side is just as important, because positioning damage for one brand is almost always positioning opportunity for another. The European and Swiss providers didn’t run a clever campaign. They just happened to be standing in exactly the right place when the ground shifted, and their long-ignored message “we’re outside that reach” suddenly became the most valuable sentence in enterprise software.

The sovereign cloud market, by the way, is projected to grow from around $154 billion in 2025 to over $800 billion by 2032. That is the scale of a positioning shift that got triggered, in large part, by a single incident and one law most people had never heard of.

The One Thing to Sit With

You now compete on an axis that barely existed three years ago: can you be turned against your own customer? For most brands, that question will never come up. But for anyone selling infrastructure, trust, or continuity across borders, it is now a live part of the buying decision, and no feature list makes it go away.

That’s the real story here. Not the politics. The positioning. Trust was the product; the product got recalled in front of the whole world, and now every serious buyer is asking a question they didn’t used to ask. The companies that understand that and answer it honestly rather than with a rebrand are the ones who’ll come out of this era with their standing intact.